NBS Hack Week: Pilot study on ARRIVE guidelines E10 compliance
The ARRIVE (Animal Research: Reporting of In Vivo Experiments) guidelines are reportingguidelines designed to improve transparency and facilitate critical assessment ofexperiments involving animal research. Although it represents essential reportinginformation for animal experiments, compliance with ARRIVE items is not commonlydemanded by journals and is often lacking in animal studies. In this small pilot project, weevaluated compliance with ARRIVE 2.0 essential 10 items in 64 papers from 2018 and 2020,either citing or not the ARRIVE manuscripts. Papers that cited the ARRIVE guidelines hadslightly higher reporting scores, but we did not detect an effect of the time period nor aninteraction effect between ARRIVE versions 1.0 and 2.0. This work was conducted during theNo-Budget Science Hack Week 2021 event, an extended hackathon to discuss and developprojects in metascience. In future work, this pilot can be expanded to better estimate theeffects of the ARRIVE guidelines on reporting practices.
Figures
Distribution of journals in each sample group. The frequency of papers analyzed from each journal is represented by b...
Distribution of journals in each sample group. The frequency of papers analyzed from each journal is represented by both the size and color of dots (n = 16 per group).
Distribution of compliance scores A) for each evaluated group, B) between papers either citing or not citing any vers...
Distribution of compliance scores A) for each evaluated group, B) between papers either citing or not citing any version of ARRIVE and C) between papers from 2018 or 2020, regardless of citing or not ARRIVE. p-values are presented from a 2-way ANOVA comparing group scores using time, ARRIVE citation and their interaction as factors. Sample size is n=16 articles per group, and n=32 when comparing only ARRIVE and Time factors.